Q&A: AI loss scenarios and claims developments 

Questions and answers | November 2026

Artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming business at extraordinary speed, but the perils are evolving just as fast. This Q&A looks at how AI is changing the risk and insurance claims landscape, and highlights what businesses can do to better understand, manage, and transfer AI-related risks, drawing on key insights from Allianz Commercial’s experts. 

The pace of change has been remarkable. AI surged from number 10 to 2 in the annual Allianz Risk Barometer – the largest year-on-year rise of any risk category. Businesses and risk professionals now recognize that AI is not simply a technology issue. It is a fundamental business, governance, and leadership challenge. 

Dependencies on AI have grown rapidly. Many companies are already reliant on the technology for critical operations – from autonomous systems and customer interactions to production planning and pricing models. The opportunities are immense, but so is the exposure. 

Based on current claims data alone, AI would not rank even in the top 20 loss drivers for businesses and insurers. But that figure is deeply misleading. AI losses are frequently underreported, difficult to quantify, or recorded under traditional categories such as cyber, directors' and officers' liability, or product liability insurance. The true risk exposure is substantial and growing fast. 

AI-related incidents and litigation are accelerating significantly. The number of tracked AI incidents rose from 179 in 2023 to 307 in 2024 and 453 in 2025, according to the MIT AI Risk Initiative (as of October 7, 2026) – and that upwards trajectory shows no sign of slowing. AI-related securities class action lawsuits in the US are on pace to nearly double the 2025 total. Allianz Commercial is already tracking AI-related insurance claims with substantial values in the millions of euros. A sharp increase in losses should be anticipated. 

Allianz Commercial is developing a framework built around four main categories, which helps businesses and insurers understand where the exposures lie. 

The first is direct AI loss. This is where the AI system itself is the primary cause of harm through an incorrect action, decision, recommendation or output. Examples include cases where an AI-generated advice subsequently causes a financial loss or an AI-driven process failure causes operational disruption or results in physical damage – such as when defective AI safety systems in vehicles are said to have contributed to an automotive accident. 

The second is AI-related loss – where AI is a material factor, but the harm arises from surrounding governance, legal, reputational or third-party AI issues rather than the insured’s own AI system. Directors' and officers' liability is a prime example with trends such as AI washing – where companies overstate or misrepresent their AI capabilities – helping to drive a growing wave of securities litigation. In a recent survey Allianz Commercial conducted with The D&O Diary, 86% of respondents said they believed AI-related claims will significantly impact the D&O insurance landscape, and 92% said poor AI governance increases the likelihood of claims. 

The third category is AI-accelerated loss. Here, AI does not cause the loss directly but enables, scales, or accelerates malicious activity. Cyber crime is the most prominent example. AI is already widely used to create the likes of more convincing phishing attacks and deepfakes, to develop malware, and automate attacks. AI-related cyber crime is estimated to have cost US citizens close to US$1trn in 2025 alone, according to some estimates. 

Finally, there is AI-dependency loss. This occurs when an event which is not caused by AI is made significantly worse because of a heavy reliance on AI-driven processes and insufficient fallback capabilities. There have been cases where cyber outages forced companies to revert to manual, paper-based processes – resulting in massive operational disruption and millions in lost revenue per day. 

AI carries a unique systemic risk profile. Unlike previous technology revolutions, it is being adopted simultaneously across virtually all industries and geographies. Many AI systems share common foundations – the same large language models, training data, cloud infrastructure, and data centers. This concentration means a single flaw, outage, or vulnerability could cascade across sectors and borders. 

AI also operates probabilistically. Errors are inevitable, even in well-designed systems. When deployed at scale, even a small error rate can generate a massive number of incidents simultaneously. That is a fundamentally different risk dynamic to what has been managed before. 

While AI introduces new risk exposures, it can simultaneously reduce the frequency and severity of existing risks when deployed with appropriate governance and human oversight. 

In financial services, AI-driven fraud detection identifies suspicious transactions in real time. In cyber security, AI detects abnormal network activity and emerging attack patterns before significant damage occurs. Manufacturers use predictive maintenance to catch early signs of equipment failure. Allianz Commercial claims analysis shows that AI-enabled detection and response tools significantly reduce response time and business interruption costs when attacks are caught early. 

The technology is not the problem. The challenge is ensuring it is deployed responsibly, with the right controls in place. 

The most important shift is to treat AI risk as a business, governance, and leadership challenge – not just an IT issue. Organizations need clear visibility into where AI is being used, how it affects decision-making and operations, and which exposures could emerge if tools fail or produce inaccurate outputs. 

This requires deliberate decisions about which risks can be mitigated, which can be accepted, and which should be transferred through insurance. It also requires stronger collaboration across functions, because AI risks sit at the intersection of technology, legal, compliance, operations, and board accountability. 

The opportunities for AI remain significant. But realizing them sustainably depends on understanding the risk landscape early and proactively – before losses become more visible at scale. The time to prepare is now. 

Keep up to date on all news and insights from Allianz Commercial